What actually happened inside that pipe
Most people picture ice bursting a pipe outward, like a can of soda in a freezer. That is not how it works.
When water freezes inside a supply line, it forms a plug somewhere along the run. Water keeps arriving behind that plug from the house side, and it has nowhere to go, because the faucet at the other end is closed. Pressure between the ice plug and the closed fixture climbs into the thousands of psi. The pipe gives out at its weakest point, usually a longitudinal split an inch or two long in copper, or a shattered section in aged CPVC.
And then nothing happens. The ice is still sitting in the pipe, plugging the hole it just made. Everything looks fine.
The flood comes later, when the attic warms or the garage catches morning sun and the plug melts. A half-inch supply line at 60 psi puts out somewhere in the region of six to eight gallons a minute through a clean split. Overnight, that is a room. Over an eight-hour workday, that is a claim.
This is why we care so much about the timeline when you call. “It froze last night and now water is coming through the ceiling” tells us where to look before we leave the shop.
How to tell which kind of burst you have
A freeze burst
Followed a cold night. Usually an attic run, an exposed garage line, an exterior wall, or the tube behind a hose bib. Often accompanied by one fixture that produced nothing that morning while the rest of the house worked.
A pressure burst
No freeze involved. Often at a fitting, a flex connector, or a washing machine hose rather than the middle of a straight run. The tell is static pressure: put a gauge on a hose bib with everything off. If you are reading over 80 psi, your pressure reducing valve has failed or was never installed, and the pipe was living under load it was never meant to carry.
A corrosion blowout
Copper that has been thinning from the inside for twenty years finally opens up. Usually starts as a pinhole weep and a green-blue crust before it becomes a burst. If you have already patched two or three pinholes in the same house, the pipe is telling you something about the whole system, not that one spot.
A material failure
Grey polybutylene, common in homes built roughly 1978 to 1995, fails at the fittings with no warning. CPVC that has spent three decades in a valley attic, where summer temperatures routinely exceed 150°F, goes amber and brittle and cracks when something bumps it. Neither is fixed by replacing one section.
The first ten minutes matter more than anything we do
Turn the water off. That is the whole list.
Everything else, finding the break, cutting access, choosing materials, costs the same whether you call us at 9am or 9pm. What does not stay the same is how much water went into your subfloor. The difference between a homeowner who found the valve in two minutes and one who searched for twenty is often the difference between a drywall patch and replacing the flooring in two rooms.
If you take one thing from this page: go outside this weekend, find your shutoff, turn it off and back on once, and make sure everyone in the house knows where it is.
Why it comes back if you only fix the break
We get called back to houses where somebody repaired the split and left. The next winter, another section of the same uninsulated attic run lets go four feet away. Nothing went wrong with the repair, the repair was fine. The conditions that caused it never changed.
So we check three things after every burst, and they take about fifteen minutes between them. Static pressure at a hose bib. The condition and age of the pressure regulator, which typically lasts eight to twelve years in hard water. And the rest of the vulnerable footage, how much uninsulated pipe is sitting in that attic, along that garage wall, or behind that stucco. Insulating fifty feet of exposed pipe is inexpensive. Cutting another ceiling open is not.
What it costs, honestly
What a burst costs comes down to access. An exposed run you can point at, copper in the garage, a split under a sink, a hose bib, is the simple version of the job. Once the break is inside a wall, a ceiling or an attic, the price is driven by how far we have to open, how awkward the run is, and the pressure testing and closing up that follow.
Those numbers are plumbing only. Drying equipment, mold remediation, drywall and flooring belong to a restoration contractor, and we will say plainly whether you need one rather than quietly working around standing water.
If the burst is a symptom of a whole system at the end of its life, polybutylene, failing galvanized, copper on its third pinhole, we will tell you that too, and give you a repipe figure alongside the repair figure so you can decide with real numbers instead of a feeling. That repipe figure is driven by the size of the house, the number of stories and how reachable the runs are.
You get the price before we start. It does not move unless we open the wall and find something genuinely different, and then we stop and show you first.