What that crackling in the garage really means
It tends to happen on a quiet evening. You hear the burner catch, and moments later the heater starts crackling like oil in a hot pan before it settles into a low rumble. Some nights it knocks loudly enough to hear from the kitchen.
The noise starts at the base of the heater. Over time a layer of grit and mineral crust builds across the tank floor, right above the burner on a gas unit or around the bottom element of an electric model. Water gets caught in and under that layer, overheats, and flashes into small steam bubbles that collapse with a pop. The heater still works, but now it heats through a blanket. Each cycle runs longer, the steel at the base gets pushed beyond what it was built for, and the tank holds less usable hot water because sediment is taking up the space.
A noisy heater is not an emergency on its own. It is a warning that the tank is working harder than it should, and it is usually the least expensive moment to deal with it.
Where the grit comes from in Exeter
Exeter’s water does not come from a river or a reservoir. The City pumps it from its own groundwater wells, five active chlorinated wells plus a standby, ranging from 296 to 620 feet deep. That source affects your water heater in two ways.
First, sand. The Water Division is upfront that sand turns up naturally in groundwater, and that a repair on a City line can send a burst of it down the pipes. The City reports no health concern from it, but heavy grains do not stay suspended once they reach a still tank of water. They sink and stay put. If the City has worked on a line near you lately and the hot side suddenly turned gritty, that is the likely explanation.
Second, hardness. The City’s 2025 Consumer Confidence Report gives 160 mg/L as the typical hardness, with individual wells anywhere from 110 to 230 mg/L (sampled in 2022). That is close to 9.3 grains per gallon on average and over 13 at the top of the spread, which the USGS classes as hard. Cold water holds those minerals comfortably. Heat drives them out as scale, and the water heater is the hottest spot in your plumbing.
So an Exeter tank collects two kinds of debris: sand that arrives with the water, and scale that forms inside the tank. They pile up together, and that combined layer is what pours out when we open the drain on a popping heater. Regular flushing and tank maintenance removes most of it before it hardens. If scale is the bigger share of the problem, a softener for Exeter’s hard water slows how fast it returns.
A few checks worth doing before you call
Some no-hot-water calls do not need a plumber at all, and we would rather you knew that.
- Gas heater, no hot water. Look through the sight window for the pilot or burner flame. If the pilot is out, the relighting steps are printed on the label on the tank. If it lights and then dies when you release the knob, the thermocouple or flame sensor is the likely culprit, and that is a repair.
- Electric heater, no hot water. Check the breaker panel. A breaker that tripped once can be reset. One that trips again is telling you an element or wire has failed, so leave it off and call.
- Lukewarm water only. Make sure nobody turned the temperature dial down. If the setting is right, sediment, a failed element or a broken dip tube are the usual suspects.
- Milky or white hot water. Fill a clear glass and wait. If it clears from the bottom up, that was air, which the City traces to faucet aerators. Grit that sinks is a different story.
Repair it or replace it
Most failures on a working tank are parts that can be swapped: thermocouples, igniters, gas control valves, heating elements, thermostats, relief valves, drain valves, dip tubes and anode rods. When the tank itself is sound, repairing it is usually the sensible choice.
The tank shell is where repair ends. Once water is weeping from the steel body or seeping out from under the outer jacket, there is nothing left to patch. In that case we walk you through replacing the water heater, including whether a different type would suit the house better, and we do not push you to decide on the spot.
Age alone does not settle it. An older tank can still be worth a new part, and a younger one can be beyond saving. Condition decides it, and we show you the condition rather than asking you to take our word for it.
How we price a water heater repair
We do not quote repairs over the phone, because one symptom can have several causes with very different fixes. A lukewarm shower might be a thermostat, an element, a dip tube or a tank half full of sediment. What moves the price is which part failed, whether the heater runs on gas or electricity, how easy the tank is to reach, and whether a flush has to happen first so the repair actually holds.
We diagnose first. The repair figure goes on paper before work starts, and it stays put unless we find something unexpected and you agree to the change. A true middle-of-the-night callout carries an after-hours rate, and you hear what it is on the phone before we come.
Getting hot water back today
Our shop is in Exeter, owner Jim Smith has run it since 2021, and a water heater problem in town is close to home for our licensed techs, so same-day service is the norm. We are bonded, insured and licensed (CSLB #1072777), and the phone is answered 24/7, weekends and holidays included.
If your heater is popping, leaking or handing out cold showers, call (559) 648-6871. Describe what you are hearing or seeing, and you will get a straight answer on whether it needs us tonight or can wait for a scheduled visit.